Trendy foods have long made their way onto grocery store shelves touting nutritional labels dense with vitamins and minerals that consumers are informed they should covet. The ‘next’ ‘new’ nutritionally dense food on the market is often deemed a ‘Superfood’.
However, Professor Philip B. Stark tells us that true Superfoods are more local than we might imagine.
Superfoods are planted in social consciousness through advertising and then make their way onto menus and into grocery bags. Later, investigative journalists often reveal the negative impacts caused by growing, harvesting or transporting said foods and how sudden consumer preference for them rapidly intensifies these issues; exemplified in the effect of almonds on California’s water supply, or the impact of avocados on Mexican farmers. The buzzword ‘Superfood’ is now infamous for its ability to draw consumers to any product, even a problematic one.
The following interview has been lightly edited for grammar and clarity.
The Power of Weeds
Many of these edible weeds are incredibly, nutritionally dense. They compare very favorably to spinach or kale or other things that we think of as especially nutritious greens. They are superfoods in that sense…
Forging greens is interesting because the barriers to it largely have to do with how separated we have become from the source of our own food. In the global north we have a food clergy that tells us what is and isn’t food, that blesses things that are supposed to be eaten.
How do you know whether something has been blessed by the clergy? Well, it’s presented to you on a plate at a restaurant or it’s on the grocery store shelf. It’s in a plastic bag. It has some signs that it has been sanctified. And when food has been sanctified, we don’t worry about where it came from. We don’t imagine it actually growing in soil.
Foraged, Local, Organic and Free
Professor Stark is often asked about the cleanliness of foraged food, and responds that we may need to question the cleanliness of all the food we eat:
Think about this head of lettuce that is on the grocery store shelf.
It was Euell Gibbons who loosely said: Think about who’s hands planted it, the herbicides and fertilizers and whatnot that were dumped on it, whose hands harvested it, put it on a truck. It went down the highway, was exposed to exhaust, exposed to brake dust, was unloaded by another set of hands put on the shelf by another set of hands picked over by 23 other consumers before you picked it up. Right. And in contrast, that dandelion growing next to the sidewalk, you’re probably the first human being to touch it.
It’s hard to get anything that is more local or fresher than edible things that are growing in your own front yard or along the sidewalk.
Foraging as Practice
Professor Stark is clear that he does not see foraging as a large scale food solution but rather a way for us to reconnect with our food and enhance our diets:
There are certainly parts of the world where foraging is an important source of nutrition on a daily basis. Ranging from Mediterranean region, Southeast Asia, South America, Central America. There’s a lot of parts of the world where foraging really is part of how people put food on the table. In addition to whatever it is that that they’re growing deliberately, farming or ranching and so on.
There’s a reason we have agriculture.
It was a lot more successful than being hunter gatherers and enabled us to accumulate surpluses and so on. I don’t think that humanity wants to go back to foraging and being hunter gatherers.
But, it’s great as a way of getting in touch with your inner naturalist and feeling kind of quintessentially human. It’s terrific as a as a way of getting some flavors and textures and phytonutrients and whatnot that you might otherwise not get into your diet.